We Cannot Neglect Nuclear Disarmament

William Lambers
President Ronald Reagan once called for "the total elimination one day of nuclear weapons from the face of the Earth."

But Reagan's great aspiration seems far off today. Both Russia and the United States hold thousands of nuclear weapons despite existing arms control treaties. China, India, Pakistan, Britain and France all possess smaller but sizable arsenals. North Korea has tested its first nuclear weapon. In the Middle East, Israel has the bomb, and Iran may be joining the nuclear club. When one thinks of the horrific scenarios that could emerge from all this proliferation, including nuclear terrorism, disarmament never looked so desirable.

Ever since the end of the Cold War, there have been calls for aggressively moving forward on nuclear disarmament. In 1996 two retired generals, Lee Butler and Andrew Goodpaster, put forth a plan for the nuclear states to begin deep reductions in their arsenals, with an eye toward eventual nuclear disarmament. The United States and Russia would take the lead in these reductions, even down to the level of 100-200 nuclear weapons each. Other nuclear states would cap their arsenals at "very low levels." Throughout this process, confidence- building and verification measures would be strengthened among the states to guarantee each step.

The United States would be wise to follow the principles of the Goodpaster-Butler plan and President Obama appears to be headed in that direction. Just this week, Obama and Russian President Dmitry Medvedev announced negotiations on reducing both countries nuclear arsenals.

Obama has also stated his support for the Comprehensive Test Ban Treaty to eliminate nuclear test explosions, which the U.S. failed to ratify in 1999.

The United States needs to partner with Russia in the elimination of nuclear weapons, not open the door for a new arms race. More nuclear disarmament talks could even ease Russian concerns over the U.S. plan to place a missile defense shield in Europe.


Back in 1996, the Goodpaster-Butler plan was centered on President Eisenhower's notion that "nuclear weapons are the only thing that can destroy the United States." Indeed, Goodpaster and Butler were forward-thinking when they cited nuclear terrorism as among the reasons for disarmament. Nearly five years after their proposal, the world was awakened to the threat posed by terrorists on Sept. 11, 2001. People can now imagine what catastrophe would result should terrorists get hold of a nuclear weapon.

Goodpaster and Butler cited nuclear accidents as another reason for taking disarmament steps. The 2007 fiasco of nuclear-armed missiles being accidentally transported over the United States on a B-52 shows the dangers of having these weapons around.

Maintaining nuclear weapons is a major expense for nations to carry. This financial burden takes away from other national priorities including conventional military forces, intelligence gathering to prevent terrorism and homeland security. We should also remember Eisenhower's philosophy that armaments represent "a theft from those who hunger and are not fed, those who are cold and are not clothed."

It is imperative for the United States to regain the initiative on nuclear disarmament. Gaining Russia's full cooperation, beginning with further bilateral nuclear arms reductions, is an essential first step. Failure to do so leaves future generations exposed to the threat of nuclear terrorism and accidents, not to mention massive expenditures for unnecessary weapons. A nuclear-free world must not remain a distant hope but rather a goal vigorously pursued in a spirit of unprecedented international cooperation.

How can someone get involved in promoting nuclear disarmament? A new campaign, titled Global Zero, is asking the public to get involved in the elimination of nuclear arsenals. You can join Global Zero by visiting their web site.
Print Email
Bookmark and Share

William Lambers

William Lambers is the author of several books including "Ending World Hunger: School Lunches for Kids Around the World." This book features over 50 interviews with officials from the UN World Food Programme, Catholic Relief Services, World Vision, Shakira's Barefoot Foundation and ChildsLife International. The interviews, arranged by country, detail school feeding programs that fight child hunger. His articles have been published by the History News Network, the Cincinnati Enquirer, the Chicago Sun-Times, the San Diego Union-Tribune, the New York Times and the Bakersfield Californian. His series of interviews with officials from the UN World Food Programme is also available on the American Chronicle site.

Got Debt?  Get Debt Wise.