It is more a Kashmir Valley problem than a J&K problem : Kashmir Dispute ???
Daya Sagar Sharma
November 02, 2011
Jeh Jammu Kashmir ke logoan ka durbagay hi hai ki 1947 ke bharat ke saath accession ke baad bhi jahan ke log har din ek neyee bhool bhuleyeian mein apnea aap ko khada patae hain. Lucknow ke badae emaam badaa ki bhulbhuleyeian ka to raasta kush soch vichaar ke baad koyee khoj sakta hai par jo khel jammu Kashmir ke logoan ke sath satta mein baethae aur satta ke bhar ke neta kheltae hain bo bahoot hi jatil hain. Oos se bhi badae dukh ki baat yeh hai ki kush smajik karaykarta , kush apnea ko human rights activist kehnae balae aur kush aglee panktee mein khadae honae ki aas rakhnae balae patrakaar bhi Jammu Kashmir ke visheon ko vivadit deeshaon mein dhakelnae mein lagae dikhtae hain.
Eis se bhi ajeeb baat yeh hai ki kush log jo Jammu Kashmir reasat ke barae mein naheen ke barabar jantae hain aur Kashmir Ghatee ko hi Jammu Kashmir smajtae hain bo bhi bade aasani se badae jatil visheon par vayaan baazee kar detae hain. Esee shrinkhla mein pichlae denoan mein bahut hi gair jmmae daraana , prasthition ke vipreet aur rashtr ka ahit karnae balae kush vaktabaya J&K ke barae mein aeyae hain. Pehlae 25 september ko delhi ke aek vakil Sh Prashant Bhusan ne Banaras mein media se baat karate huyae kaha ki Kashmir se AFSPA ko hata lena chahiyae , bahan se suraksha baloan ko bhi hata dena chahiyae taa ki manav adhikaroan ka hanan na ho sakae aur Kashmir mein janmat sangreh karana chahiyae aur yadee bahaan ke log bharat ke saath nahin rehna chatae to oon ko alg honae dena chahiyae. Oon ka yeh bayaan 12 October ko oon ke chamber mein huyee apriyae ghatan ke baad lagataar TV channels mein deekhaeya geyaa. Oos ke baad 13 Oct ko Prashant Bhushan jee ka ek interview IBN / CNN ke Rajdeep ke saath youtube par daala geyaa gis mein Prashant Bhushan jee ne apnea vaktabay mein koyee burayee nahin honae ka daaba keeya aur jab Rajdeep ne oon se poocha ki kush log Kashmir mein plebiscite ke baat karne ko anti national act kehtae hain to oon hon ne ek vakil ke dang se oolta sabaal keeya ki Jawahar Lal Nehru ne bhi UN mein kaha tha ki bharat Kashmir mein plebiscite karbaey ga to phir oon ko ( Nehru ) anti national keon nahi kehtae. Takniki tor par shayad Bhusan jee ko jabab deeya ja shakta tha par oon ke yeh kehane se jo sandesh aam soch balae vayaktee ke paas aur bahar desh ke logoan me aur khaas kar shankaon me fanstae ja rahae Kashmir ghati ke nagrik ko jataa hai bo jakinan achcha nahin hai. Oon ki eis daleel (argument ) ka jabab Delhi se ( Khaas kar ke Congress ke shirsh netriv se aana chahiyae tha , par nahin aeyaa ) beena samay khoyae aana chahiyae tha par aaj paanch din beet janae ke baad bhi nahin aeyaa.
Bhushan jee ne daleel di ki yeh oon ka jaatee vichar tha aur eis ka oon ko adhikaar tha, par bo yeh bhool geyae ki agar bo sirt ek vakil hotae to koyee oon ko sunnae nahin aata , par keyon ki bo rato raat Janlok pal movement se jud kar eka public figure ban geyae hain eis liyae oon ki koyee cheej jo publically kahee jaey gi oon ki jaatee nahin rehtee. Oon ke aesae vaktabaon se jakinan desh ka vatavaran bigda hai aur oon ko eis par khed vayakt karna chahiyae tha jaisae ke oon par huyae hamlae ke liyae sab ne keeya tha.
Jahantak surakhsha balaon ko hatanae ki baat hai aur AFSPA ko hatanae ki baat hai Bhushan ji jo aaj Jan Lokpal movement ki bajah se surkhion mein hain ek achchae vakil honae ke natae yeh to smjatae hongae ki AF ( Jammu & KASHMIR )SPA Act 1990 aur Disturbed area Act jaroorat ke heesaab se lagaeya jaata hai na ki logoan ko dbanae ke liyae. Par oon ke bayaan se dunia ko sandesh jaata hai ki bharat ne Kashmir ke logoan ko taakat se dabaa rakha hai, jo keesee bhi drishti se sach / uchit vichar nahin hai. Doosari baat jo eis se bahar nekalti hai bo jeh hai ki Prashant Bhushan jaesae log J&K ko sirf Kashmir Gahti samajatae hain jab ki Kashmir gahtee se 160 % bada jammu region hai aur Kashmir ghatee se keyee gunaa bad ladakh region hai .Par accession , security forces aur AFSPA lagae janae ke khilaaf avajein sif Kashmir gahtee ke netao ki tarah se oothee hain.
Bharat ke grehmantralay dwara jo teen vartatakaron ( interlocutors ) ki team 13 October 2010 ko neeyukt ki geyee thee oos ne theek ek saal baad 12 Oct ko grehmantri P Chidambram jee ko apnee report saump dee hai. Vartakaroan ke dwara media ke samnae kahee geyee kush batoan ke adhaar par kush logoan ne yeh bhi anumaan lagayae hain ki vartakaroan ne jammu Kashmir mein suraksha baloan ki deployment aur AF ( Jammu Kashmir ) SPA Act 1990 ke vishay mein bhi apnee report mein kush aesee sifarishein ki hain . Agar aesa hai to eis mein koyee buree baat nahin hai agarchae ki yeh aasha bhi ki ja sakti hai ki vartakaron ne apni report mein yeh bhi kahaa hoga ki kin kin elakoan mein central suraksha forces ko laganae ki jaroorat nahin hai. Aur agar aesa hoga to jakinan vahaan se forces hat jaein ghee aur AFSPA ka eistmaal nahin hoga.
AF ( Jammu Kashmir ) SPA Act 1990 par casual dang se deeyae geyae beanoan ne kush logoan ko eis Vishay mein baat karnae aur sarkaar ka virod prakat karnae ka moka de deeya hai. Kush logoan ne yeh bhi kahaa hai ki PM dwara banaey geyae ek WG jis ke adaksh aaj ke Vice-President Hamid Ansari hain ne bhi 3 saal pehlae kaha tapni report mein kaha tha ki Armed Forces Special Powers Act and Disturbed Areas Act ko khatam karna chahiyae. Par aesae log WG ki report ke oos hissae ko undekha kar detae hain jis mein kaha geyaa ki jahaan armed forces ki jaroorat nahin hai bahaan se oon ko hata lenaa chahiyae. Eis liyae Yadee rajay sarkaar hi yeh keh detee ki Kashmir gahtee mein oos ko rashtriyae suraksha baloan aur sena ki jaroorat civil areas mein nahin ha to oon ko hata liyaa geyaa hota , aesae kush elkoan ko disturbed area Act se bahar kar deeya jaata. Esee batein karnae balae sirf aam admi ko gumrah karna chahtae hain .
It was on 16th Oct 2011 that a protest march from Pratap Park Srinagar to Imphal ( where Irom Sharmila is in ptotest on fast at Jawahar Lal Nehru hospital ) was given start from Srinagar for revocation of the Armed Forces Special Powers Act (AFSPA) in Jammu and Kashmir and North Eastern states . And to flag it off Medha Patekar and Dr .Sandeep Pandey had come to Srinagar with a few more associates. Local media reported anti-AFSPA, anti-forces and pro-freedom slogans filled the air. Medha Patkar reportedly said "We denounce all kinds of violence & we don´t want Army rule in J&K or other parts of India. There are unlawful killings, disappearances and arbitrary arrests in the areas where this law is in vogue," Accusation on security forces by such like social activists even if are false but they do reach the world and hence either they should be addressed to by GOI / State , and if false such people should not be allowed to create disturbance and distrust amongst the people of States like J&K. Where were Meedha and Sanjeev for last 11 years , why did not they go sit in Imphal with Irom Sharmila ?
It was not over there. Speaking on the occasion Sabdeep Pandey too like Prashant Bhushan said that Kashmiris should be given the right to self-determination to decide their fate .In case they are so much concerned for the separatists in Kashmir Valley why do not they come there along with their family and stay in the rural areas of J&K and carry on the movement for plebiscite and removal of security forces from civilian area instead of paying occasional visits simply to disturb peace in J&K.
Eis prakaar ke log J&K ke logoan ka bhala nahin kar saktae keyon ke bo J&K ko nahin jantae hain. Haan etna jaroor hai ki kush alagabbadi tatboan ne Prashant Bhushan jee ko kaafee saraha hai.
With the activities of such like human rights activists and social workers in Kashmir Valley and outside J&K now the time has come that GOI acknowledges that what ever resentments against India are emerging or are being cultivated are only in Kashmir Valley and not in whole of J&K. Enough price has been paid and time lost . It is more a Kashmir Valley problem than a J&K problem.
(Daya Sagar is a social activist and Sr.columnist on J&K affairs dayasagr45@yahoo.com 09419796096)
Eis se bhi ajeeb baat yeh hai ki kush log jo Jammu Kashmir reasat ke barae mein naheen ke barabar jantae hain aur Kashmir Ghatee ko hi Jammu Kashmir smajtae hain bo bhi bade aasani se badae jatil visheon par vayaan baazee kar detae hain. Esee shrinkhla mein pichlae denoan mein bahut hi gair jmmae daraana , prasthition ke vipreet aur rashtr ka ahit karnae balae kush vaktabaya J&K ke barae mein aeyae hain. Pehlae 25 september ko delhi ke aek vakil Sh Prashant Bhusan ne Banaras mein media se baat karate huyae kaha ki Kashmir se AFSPA ko hata lena chahiyae , bahan se suraksha baloan ko bhi hata dena chahiyae taa ki manav adhikaroan ka hanan na ho sakae aur Kashmir mein janmat sangreh karana chahiyae aur yadee bahaan ke log bharat ke saath nahin rehna chatae to oon ko alg honae dena chahiyae. Oon ka yeh bayaan 12 October ko oon ke chamber mein huyee apriyae ghatan ke baad lagataar TV channels mein deekhaeya geyaa. Oos ke baad 13 Oct ko Prashant Bhushan jee ka ek interview IBN / CNN ke Rajdeep ke saath youtube par daala geyaa gis mein Prashant Bhushan jee ne apnea vaktabay mein koyee burayee nahin honae ka daaba keeya aur jab Rajdeep ne oon se poocha ki kush log Kashmir mein plebiscite ke baat karne ko anti national act kehtae hain to oon hon ne ek vakil ke dang se oolta sabaal keeya ki Jawahar Lal Nehru ne bhi UN mein kaha tha ki bharat Kashmir mein plebiscite karbaey ga to phir oon ko ( Nehru ) anti national keon nahi kehtae. Takniki tor par shayad Bhusan jee ko jabab deeya ja shakta tha par oon ke yeh kehane se jo sandesh aam soch balae vayaktee ke paas aur bahar desh ke logoan me aur khaas kar shankaon me fanstae ja rahae Kashmir ghati ke nagrik ko jataa hai bo jakinan achcha nahin hai. Oon ki eis daleel (argument ) ka jabab Delhi se ( Khaas kar ke Congress ke shirsh netriv se aana chahiyae tha , par nahin aeyaa ) beena samay khoyae aana chahiyae tha par aaj paanch din beet janae ke baad bhi nahin aeyaa.
Bhushan jee ne daleel di ki yeh oon ka jaatee vichar tha aur eis ka oon ko adhikaar tha, par bo yeh bhool geyae ki agar bo sirt ek vakil hotae to koyee oon ko sunnae nahin aata , par keyon ki bo rato raat Janlok pal movement se jud kar eka public figure ban geyae hain eis liyae oon ki koyee cheej jo publically kahee jaey gi oon ki jaatee nahin rehtee. Oon ke aesae vaktabaon se jakinan desh ka vatavaran bigda hai aur oon ko eis par khed vayakt karna chahiyae tha jaisae ke oon par huyae hamlae ke liyae sab ne keeya tha.
Jahantak surakhsha balaon ko hatanae ki baat hai aur AFSPA ko hatanae ki baat hai Bhushan ji jo aaj Jan Lokpal movement ki bajah se surkhion mein hain ek achchae vakil honae ke natae yeh to smjatae hongae ki AF ( Jammu & KASHMIR )SPA Act 1990 aur Disturbed area Act jaroorat ke heesaab se lagaeya jaata hai na ki logoan ko dbanae ke liyae. Par oon ke bayaan se dunia ko sandesh jaata hai ki bharat ne Kashmir ke logoan ko taakat se dabaa rakha hai, jo keesee bhi drishti se sach / uchit vichar nahin hai. Doosari baat jo eis se bahar nekalti hai bo jeh hai ki Prashant Bhushan jaesae log J&K ko sirf Kashmir Gahti samajatae hain jab ki Kashmir gahtee se 160 % bada jammu region hai aur Kashmir ghatee se keyee gunaa bad ladakh region hai .Par accession , security forces aur AFSPA lagae janae ke khilaaf avajein sif Kashmir gahtee ke netao ki tarah se oothee hain.
Bharat ke grehmantralay dwara jo teen vartatakaron ( interlocutors ) ki team 13 October 2010 ko neeyukt ki geyee thee oos ne theek ek saal baad 12 Oct ko grehmantri P Chidambram jee ko apnee report saump dee hai. Vartakaroan ke dwara media ke samnae kahee geyee kush batoan ke adhaar par kush logoan ne yeh bhi anumaan lagayae hain ki vartakaroan ne jammu Kashmir mein suraksha baloan ki deployment aur AF ( Jammu Kashmir ) SPA Act 1990 ke vishay mein bhi apnee report mein kush aesee sifarishein ki hain . Agar aesa hai to eis mein koyee buree baat nahin hai agarchae ki yeh aasha bhi ki ja sakti hai ki vartakaron ne apni report mein yeh bhi kahaa hoga ki kin kin elakoan mein central suraksha forces ko laganae ki jaroorat nahin hai. Aur agar aesa hoga to jakinan vahaan se forces hat jaein ghee aur AFSPA ka eistmaal nahin hoga.
AF ( Jammu Kashmir ) SPA Act 1990 par casual dang se deeyae geyae beanoan ne kush logoan ko eis Vishay mein baat karnae aur sarkaar ka virod prakat karnae ka moka de deeya hai. Kush logoan ne yeh bhi kahaa hai ki PM dwara banaey geyae ek WG jis ke adaksh aaj ke Vice-President Hamid Ansari hain ne bhi 3 saal pehlae kaha tapni report mein kaha tha ki Armed Forces Special Powers Act and Disturbed Areas Act ko khatam karna chahiyae. Par aesae log WG ki report ke oos hissae ko undekha kar detae hain jis mein kaha geyaa ki jahaan armed forces ki jaroorat nahin hai bahaan se oon ko hata lenaa chahiyae. Eis liyae Yadee rajay sarkaar hi yeh keh detee ki Kashmir gahtee mein oos ko rashtriyae suraksha baloan aur sena ki jaroorat civil areas mein nahin ha to oon ko hata liyaa geyaa hota , aesae kush elkoan ko disturbed area Act se bahar kar deeya jaata. Esee batein karnae balae sirf aam admi ko gumrah karna chahtae hain .
It was on 16th Oct 2011 that a protest march from Pratap Park Srinagar to Imphal ( where Irom Sharmila is in ptotest on fast at Jawahar Lal Nehru hospital ) was given start from Srinagar for revocation of the Armed Forces Special Powers Act (AFSPA) in Jammu and Kashmir and North Eastern states . And to flag it off Medha Patekar and Dr .Sandeep Pandey had come to Srinagar with a few more associates. Local media reported anti-AFSPA, anti-forces and pro-freedom slogans filled the air. Medha Patkar reportedly said "We denounce all kinds of violence & we don´t want Army rule in J&K or other parts of India. There are unlawful killings, disappearances and arbitrary arrests in the areas where this law is in vogue," Accusation on security forces by such like social activists even if are false but they do reach the world and hence either they should be addressed to by GOI / State , and if false such people should not be allowed to create disturbance and distrust amongst the people of States like J&K. Where were Meedha and Sanjeev for last 11 years , why did not they go sit in Imphal with Irom Sharmila ?
It was not over there. Speaking on the occasion Sabdeep Pandey too like Prashant Bhushan said that Kashmiris should be given the right to self-determination to decide their fate .In case they are so much concerned for the separatists in Kashmir Valley why do not they come there along with their family and stay in the rural areas of J&K and carry on the movement for plebiscite and removal of security forces from civilian area instead of paying occasional visits simply to disturb peace in J&K.
Eis prakaar ke log J&K ke logoan ka bhala nahin kar saktae keyon ke bo J&K ko nahin jantae hain. Haan etna jaroor hai ki kush alagabbadi tatboan ne Prashant Bhushan jee ko kaafee saraha hai.
With the activities of such like human rights activists and social workers in Kashmir Valley and outside J&K now the time has come that GOI acknowledges that what ever resentments against India are emerging or are being cultivated are only in Kashmir Valley and not in whole of J&K. Enough price has been paid and time lost . It is more a Kashmir Valley problem than a J&K problem.
(Daya Sagar is a social activist and Sr.columnist on J&K affairs dayasagr45@yahoo.com 09419796096)
Print
Email
